Aarhus University Seal

Peer feedback strengthens students’ ability to participate in the healthcare debate 

Short description

Students discuss a number of op-eds on healthcare in written assignments where they build their arguments based on the theoretical foundation of the course. Students give and receive peer feedback on each assignment, which they actively use in their next assignment. Students strengthen their academic argumentation skills throughout the course. The assignments also serve as the students’ overall assessment. 

Motivation

  • As this is the first course in the degree programme, it's important to build students' confidence early on by making them feel that they can contribute valuable insights to the healthcare debate.  

  • Although all the students already have nursing degrees, the academic level varies greatly, as some have many years of experience in clinical practice while others have only recently graduated. It’s important to find some common ground for their academic competencies, especially argumentation.  

  • Students often give better feedback than teachers, as they are better at pinpointing the difficult parts of an exercise. 

Learning objectives

Analyse healthcare issues to participate in social and political discussions about the healthcare sector.  

Execution

Preperation

Teacher’s preparation 

Select a number of op-eds on relevant topics in the healthcare debate. Prepare rubrics to guide the peer review process. Set up the activity in FeedbackFruits. 

Out-of-class activities 

Individually 

  • Students read two op-eds on healthcare and answer questions for discussion in a written assignment. They demonstrate understanding by using relevant theories from the course in their assignment.   

  • Students give peer feedback to two of their fellow classmates using the rubrics in FeedbackFruits. They have to critically read through each other’s assignments and argue based on the criteria in the assignment.  

  • The teacher goes through the written assignment and the feedback they have given each other. The teacher creates a feedback sheet, which acts as a kind of "feed forward". Students can use this advice in their future assignments.  

RESSOURCES FOR STUDENTS

SUPPORT FOR STUDENTS

  • Relevant theoretical texts 

  • Healthcare op-eds 

  • Rubrics to guide the process and set criteria for the assignment as well as how to give peer feedback. 

  • Feed forward to guide students in their subsequent assignments. 

Reflections

Outcomes

  • Students reflect on their own and others’ work through the peer review process, which strengthens their argumentation skills. 

  • Students have to pass at least one out of three assignments to pass the course. This exam format helps to reduce the pressure students may feel from exams in general, and they also get to experience being assessed in a different way than what they are used to. 

   

Challenges

  • Creating rubrics and setting up the activity in FeedbackFruits can take a long time and you may encounter technical challenges.  

   

Advices for other educators

  • If you don’t have experience with peer feedback or FeedbackFruits, you can get help from someone who does or contact a learning consultant from the Centre of Educational Development for technical and didactic help.  

  • It’s important to be available to students in case of technical issues or other challenges. 


Basic information

Educator Anne Bendix Andersen 
Faculty and department Department of Public Health, HEALTH 
Degree programme Nursing and Health Care 
Level of study Master’s 
Course/subject Nursing and Society 
Number of students 52
Extent Series of sessions
Implementation Autumn 2023

Contact