Aarhus University Seal

Sparring with a chatbot about assignments in collective academic supervision

Sparring with a chatbot about assignments in collective academic supervision 

Brief description

During a collective supervision session, students use a chatbot as a sparring partner to produce a written assignment. Afterwards, students reflect and discuss the process in groups. 

Your motivation

To open a dialogue with students about how chatbots can be used in academic writing processes. To give students an opportunity to try out a new way of engaging with the criteria for the written assignment. To give students an opportunity to discuss their individual experiences in a collective context. 

Learning outcomes

The purpose of the activity is for students to: 

  • gain awareness of how to use chatbots as sparring partners in their writing process 

  • familiarise themselves with the requirements for the course's written assignment 

  • practice reflecting critically on how to use chatbots and understand the learning outcomes of sparring with them 

  • get an opportunity to discuss with their peers about their shared experiences using chatbots as sparring partners in their writing process 

Describe the process

Describe the activity

Describe what happens before, during and after the teaching. 

Indicate the time spent on the individual activities. 

Before class

Group

Feedback groups for collective supervision. This course is structured to give students academic supervision in a collective context. Students are put into feedback groups of 3-4 people. 

  • Students prepare a short presentation for peer feedback on their upcoming assignment. 

  • The groups read each other’s presentations and provide peer feedback before using the chatbot.  

In class

In plenum

Introduction to the activity (10 min). Show students an example of how to spar with a chatbot. Show students where to find the requirements for the course’s assignment on Brightspace as well as a step-by-step description of the activity. 

Group

Sparring with chatbot (12 min). Students get into their feedback groups and select one person from the group to use a chatbot as a sparring partner. This person uses the presentation they prepared for student feedback and which they have already sent to the other members of the group. 

  • Students can choose which chatbot they want to use for the activity. Remember to suggest AU’s free access to Microsoft Copilot. 

  • The group members observe the interaction and make suggestions.  

  • The student uploads their own text as well as the requirements for the course assignment to the chatbot. 

  • Use the following prompt: “I have to write an assignment and I would like us to spar with each other about my assignment. I will upload a draft of my own assignment and some tips from my teacher on writing the assignment. Ask me questions that are related to specific tips from my teacher. Be honest, but also critical. Ask one question at a time and wait for my answer (insert own text here)". 

Group

Follow-up reflection (10 min). Students use the following questions to reflect in their groups: 

  • Describe your experience and observations of interacting with the chatbot as a sparring partner/process supervisor in a writing process. 

  • What potentials and challenges do you see in using chatbots in this way? 

  • How and for what do you use chatbots for academic writing (e.g. writing exercises, peer feedback, assignment writing)? 

  •  How is it different to interact with a chatbot in a group compared to individually? 

In plenum

Wrapping up (7 min). Class discussion of the students’ experiences. 

Resources for students

What resources do you make available to the students? E.g. texts, links, examples. 

Support for students

How do you support the students during the activity?  E.g. with instructions, feedback, presentations. 

  • Document describing the requirements for the course assignment  

  • Examples of similar interactions with a chatbot (slides) 

  • Short presentation explaining the purpose of the activity and showing examples 

  • Activity description including prompt and reflection questions for group discussion 

Experience

Outcomes

  • The activity gave students a space to share their experience of using chatbots for assignment writing. They learned how to focus the dialogue on their assignment by providing the chatbot with the assignment criteria.  

  • Students got to practise observing a specific supervision session and discuss the use of chatbots for assignment writing and supervision with their peers and their teacher. 

  • Students gained insight into the requirements for their written assignments in a new way.  

 

Challenges

  • Some students were initially critical about using chatbots for sparring on assignments. These students were able to take on the role of observer in the group, while another member could take on the role of sparring partner. 

      


General information

Teacher's name: Helle Merete Nordentoft and Tine Wirenfeldt Jensen 
Faculty and department/school:  Danish School of Education, Education Studies, Emdrup 
Degree program: Education studies
Level of study: Master's degree 
Course/subject Counselling as Institutional and Pedagogical Practice 
Approximate number of students 20 
When did the activity take place:  Autumn 2024 

Contact

Please contact the editors at AU Educate if you have any questions about the content of the platform or if you need consultation on your teaching from one of the many skilled professionals at the Centre for Educational Development